Thursday, September 27, 2012

Transforming the Education Debate


            This afternoon on MSNBC, there was a continuation of the Education Nation series.  Today’s topic was teacher evaluations. The town hall style meeting was held in New York with the audience consisting of educational advocates, various grade teachers, and individuals from higher education.  As I watched the broadcast, what started as promising discussion, quickly became a rehashing of the same ideas from previous Education Nation discussions.

            The broadcast did not shed any new ideas that would get our educational system back on track to producing world class students.  The reason for this that everyone views education through a narrow lens.  This lens is based on the educational experience of the individual and whatever personal, social or political agenda he/she have.  When all these individuals come together, their competing agendas take precedence over what is best for the children. 

Most people believe our educational system is not broke; it just needs to be “fixed” or “reformed.”  The band-aid approach of reform that has done to our education system is not sustainable and “wears off” after a couple of years.  More importantly, the band-aid approach has discouraged any meaningful discussion by inhibiting the voices of parents, students, and in many cases teachers from having their concerns and or ideas heard over the noise of senseless banter of the competing agendas.  This is evident in many of the discussions on educational reform by those who postulate positions on how to improve education that are out of touch with the realities in the field.  Until the narrow lens on education is widened, the language and ideology that dominates education will remain the same.  Thus, the problems plaguing education will continue and our children will fall further behind. 

            It is time to widen the lens, end the band-aid approach and change the language of fix and reform to transformation.  Our educational system continues to fail because the ideas that have been implemented are based on fix and reform.  Utilizing a transformation approach will dramatically change the direction of the discussion and the language used to create effective and sustainable change of our educational system.

A transformative approach seeks to establish a continuum of learning that assists struggling learners, supports advanced learners, prepares students to compete in a global economy and ensures our country remains an economic superpower.  By establishing a continuum of learning, the achievement gap should be greatly diminished because struggling students would have the academic support needed to get back on grade level.  Additionally, a transformative approach would also greatly diminish the engagement gap that affects teachers, parents, and students.  A transformative approach would invest in teacher trainings, provide multiple opportunities for parents to become actively involved in the education of their child and create enthusiasm for learning among students.  Lastly, a transformative approach would build a genuine parent/school partnership.

            Finally, a transformative approach will attract partnerships with institutions that habitually do not involve themselves with our educational system.  Being skeptical about the commitment to education and the preparation for the global workforce have inhibited our students from benefiting from the expertise and resources partnerships have to offer.  A transformative approach will allow potential partners to view a partnership as mutually beneficial to their institution and the country.

            If we truly want to provide our children with a world-class education we must change the approach.  The fix and reform ideology that dominates our current approach to education must be replaced with the ideology of transformation.  A transformation ideology changes the direction and discussion of our approach to education.  A transformation ideology will end the competing agendas by being inclusive of many voices to create effective and sustainable change of our educational system.

No comments:

Post a Comment